Your IP : 216.73.217.117


Current Path : /var/www/cesa.co.za/cceadmin/moderations/
Upload File :
Current File : /var/www/cesa.co.za/cceadmin/moderations/assessment_sheet_for_m3.a08_rev1.xls

��ࡱ�;��	�����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������	

 !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~�Root Entry����������������������������������������������������������������	�
�����\pCalc                                                                                                         B�a�=���=@ 8X@�"��1���Arial1���Arial1���Arial1���Arial1��Calibri1h�Calibri1�Calibri1@�Calibri1(�
�Arial Narrow1�
�Calibri1�>�Calibri1��Calibri1��Calibri1@�Calibri1��Calibri1�
�Calibri1(�
�Arial Narrow1(�
�Arial Narrow1(�
�Arial Narrow1>�Calibri1>�Calibri1�Calibri1���Calibri1��Calibri1���Calibri1���Calibri�GENERAL�GENERAL�
YYYY/MM/DD�0�@���� � ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� �� � �+�� �� �)�� �� �,�� �� �*�� �� �	�� �� ���� � ��Q � ��Q  � ��Qx"
��Q8!"� ��Qx"� ��Q 8 "� ��Qx���Qp
��Qp!
��Q
0� ��Qx
��Q|
��Qx
��Qx` 
�	�Q	x	
�
�Q
x
�	�Q	x	
�
�Q
x	
��Q H
�
�Q
x!
��Qx	
��Q|	
��Q|	
��Qx"
��Qx"
�
�Q
x 
�
�Q
x
�
�Q
x"
��Qx
��Qx!
�
�Q
x
�
�Q
x
�
�Qx
��Q
x"
�
�Qx
�
�Qx
�
�Qx
�
�Qx!
�
�Q
8� ��Q
x
��Qx
��Qx	
��Q8� ��Q8� ��Q8� ��Q8� �
�Q	8� �
�Q8� �
�Q8!� �
�Q*8� ��Q
x
��Qx
��Qx	
��Q8� ��Q8� ��Q8� ��Q8� �
�Q	8� �
�Q8� �
�Q8!� �	�Qx	
�	�Q8� ��Q
x!
��Qx!
��Q8!� ��Qx!	
��Q8!� ��Q8!� �
�Q	8!� �
�Q8!� �
�Q8!!� �	�Qx	
�	�Qx	
��Qx	
�	�Qx	
��Qx	
�
�Q(8� ��Qx	
��Qx	
��Q	x	
��Qx!	
��Qx!	
��Q	x!	
��Qx� ��Qx� ��Qx� ��Q(0� ��Qx� ��Qx� ��Qx� ��Qx!� ��Qx!� ��Qx!� ��Qx
��Qx	
��Qx	
��Q8� ��Qx	
��Qx	
��Q	x	
��Q8!� ��Qx
��Qx"	
�
�Q8� ��Q(� ��Qx!
��Qx"&	
��Q ("� ��Q ("� ��Q ( "� ��Qx� ��Q8� ��Q0� ��Q"8""� ��Q � ��Q ("� ��Q"8"� ��Qx"3��Qt"	
��Qt"3��Q|!"3��Qt"	
��Q
x""� ��Q
x2��Q
x
��Q
x	
��Q
x!	
��Q
x
��Q
x	
��Q
x
��Q8"� ��Q8""� ��Qx!
��Qx 
��Qx"
��Q
x!3��Q
x"3��Q
x3��Q"p"3��Q
x"
��Qx� ��Q0� ��Q"p
��Q"x
��Q"p2��Q"p!� ��Q @� ��Q @
��Qx� ��Q0� ��Q"p
��Q"x
��Q"p2��Q"p!� ��Qx!� ��Q0!� ��Q"p!
��Q"x!
��Q"p!2��Q"p!!� ��Q
x
��Qx� ��Q0� ��Q"p
��Q"x
��Q"p2��Q"p!� ��Q
x"
��Q ("� ��Q   "� ��Q h"���Q � ��Q8"� ��Q!8!"� ��Qx���Qx
��Qx 
�
�Q
x	
�
�Q
x 
��Q|
��Q
|
�
�Q
x!
��Q
x
�
�Qx	
�
�Q"8� ��Q
x
��Q
x!
�
�Q
x!	
��Q"8� �
�Q
x	
��Q (� �
�Q (� �
�Qx"	
�
�Qx"&	
��Q ( "� ��Q (""� ��Q � �
�Q L
��Q"� ��Qt"3��Q
|
��Q"p2��Q#x
��Q#x	
��Q#x!	
��Q#x
��Q#x	
��Q#|
��Q#x
��Q4� ��Q"p!
��Q"p"
��Q"p"
��Q `"
��Q `!"
��Q h
��Q `
��Q d
��Q4� ��Q"p!
��Q4!� ��Q"p!!
��Q"p
��Q `
��Q `!
��Q $"� �������������������Excel Built-in Normal��8�������������������������������3f�����ff���f������������������������������̙��̙3f�3����P�����fff����3f3�f333�3�3fI}333`�#�U2014 Assessmnt Master Rev 1��p Scoring Sheet� ��Re-sub  Assessmnt Master��7Re Sub Scoring Sheet ��*_xlnm.Print_Area;��	,_xlnm.Print_Area_1;��	��T��r�j�03���	�@@�
��  R�Ass NoM3.A08   Rev 1	Ass TitleConditions of ContractQuestion/SubquestionQuestion/Subquestion Eval byDate EvaluatedDate Moderated<Whole                                             Assignment�Q1.  Set up a Flow chart to determine the most suitable of the four conditions of Contract (GCC, JBCC, FIDIC and NEC) for different projects, depending on size, type, designer, pricing strategy and contracting strategy.�Q2. From Part C (Legal) of the Heritage Project case study , assuming GCC 2010 applies, analyse the four delay claims from the Wastewater Treatment Works contractor and determine which of them could be valid in terms of the contract (ignoring at this stage the quantum of the claims) and which could be rejected. Also, describe what further information would be required from the contractor by you as Engineer evaluating the claims, to substantiate the claims you consider to be valid I Evans
6,8/8, 2/9/14RulingStatus!Content/Understanding/ApplicationFacili-tatorStudentSub-mission no 1 or 2KSubmitted                          on                      time      Yes/NoE)Content/ Understand/ Application E/S/NE/R!5Satisfactory/ Good Language/ Presentation      Yes/No/:Satisfactory/ Good Effort/Origi-nality/ Innovation  Yes/No4Evaluators Remarks (A)chieved/ (N)ot achieved
 Comment)Content/ Understand/ Application E/S/NE/RCommentCeliaDyke	RamokotjoYesS� Q1.  This is correct, being based on a presentation slide, but it is noted you have added Pricing Strategy to the chart, which is useful. Your 'No' in the very centre of the chart should be lower down, opposite GCC or FIDIC Red Book, otherwise it suggests JBCC is suited to non-building works, which it is not.  Q2.  This is a concise answer but your conclusions are correct and the further information required is relevant to the claim.A5 Q1.  This is correct, being based on a presentation slide.but it is noted yiu have added Pricing Strategy to the chart, which is useful. Your 'No' in the very centre of the chart should be lower down, opposite GCC or FIDIC Red Book, otherwise it suggests JBCC is suited to non-building works, which it is not}Q2.  This is a concise answer but your conclusions are correct and the further information required is relevant to the claim.LelethuThisoQ1.  This is a good effort, enhanced by a clear description of the project in the Scope of Work. It is a little confusing where the flow chart seems to suggest one can use JBCC Minor Works, while the correct answer is NEC 3 or FIDIC Silver as shown. You also omit JBCC Principal Building Agreement from the chart, but overall you have grasped the fundamentals  Q2.  Inclusion of assumptions for all claims at start of your answer is a good way of answering the second part of the question.For the first part : Claim 1 - agree it is time barred,  Claim 2 - Good reasoning, accept time barring from the dates you assumed. Cannot be liable for penalties before reaching the Due Completion Date, they only apply if he is still working at that date. Claim 3 - You argue correctly there can be a claim, but reject it with a time bar, which is incorrect assuming 28 days from 1st Aug. Claim 4 - The discussion shows  you have studied GCC 2010 but while you state a time bar existed, your ruling allows a claim. You should state which applies. gQ1.  This is a good effort, enhanced by a clear description of the project in the Scope of Work. It is a little confusing where the flow chart seems to suggest one can use JBCC Minor Works, while the correct answer is NEC 3 or FIDIC Silver as shown. You also omit JBCC Principal Building Agreement from the chart, but overall you have grasped the fundamentals�Q2.  Inclusion of assumptions for all claims at start of your answer is a good way of answering the second part of the question.For the first part : Claim 1 - agree it is time barred,  Claim 2 - Good reasoning, accept time barring from the dates you assumed. Cannot be liable for penalties before reaching the Due Completion Date, they only apply if he is still working at that date. Claim 3 - You argue correctly there can be a claim, but reject it with a time bar, which is incorrect assuming 28 days from 1st Aug. Claim 4 - The discussion shows  you have studied GCC 2010 but while you state a time bar existed, your ruling allows a claim. You should state which applies. PieterSmitE,Q1.  A very thoroughly prepared and comprehensive flow chart, enhanced by inclusion of  Pricing Strategies available. A model answer.  Q2. You have evaluated each claim concisely but accurately, with references to relevant GCC clauses and appropriate descriptions of the further information required.�Q1.  A very thoroughly prepared and comprehensive flow chart, enhanced by inclusion of  Pricing Strategies available. A model answer.�Q2. You have evaluated each claim concisely but accurately, with references to relevant GCC clauses and appropriate descriptions of the further information required.PhilipLinhQ1.  Your flow chart is basically complete, although rather brief in places - e.g. Develop & Build by Contractor = FIDIC Silver Book, is missing, while Design by Employer cannot be FIDIC Yellow (=Red Book) Design & build by contractor = FIDIC Yellow, not Silver.   Q2.  Good analyses and conclusions regarding each claim, with key information required includedQ1.  Your flow chart is basically complete, although rather brief in places - e.g. Develop & Build by Contractor = FIDIC Silver Book, is missing, while Design by Employer cannot be FIDIC Yellow (=Red Book) Design & build by contractor = FIDIC Yellow, not Silver_Q2.  Good analyses and conclusions regarding each claim, with key information required includedCraigEricson NtuliNE�Q1.  Instead of   a flow chart you opted for a box for each Conditions of Contract but in the process you left out JBCC Minor works projects and with 2 FIDIC boxes you don't say which is Red and which is Yellow. Please ENHANCE this answer in your PoE with a flow chart, as in Slide 6 of Presentation M3.P09.   Q2. Not all your conclusions are correct: Claim 1 - agree time barred, Claim 2 - Valid because the strike is outside the contractor's control even though the workers are employed by the contractor. Claim 3 - agree because an Employer risk event . Claim 4 - Valid because although a V.O. and increase in quantities, it can cause the contractor to incur extra time and costs over what he planned for. However you have grasped the fundamentals.2Q1.  Instead of    aflow chart you opted for a box for each Conditions of Contract but in the process you left out JBCC Minor works projects and with 2 FIDIC boxes you don't say which is Red and which is Yellow. Please ENHANCE this answer in your PoE with a flow chart, as in Slide 6 of Presentation M3.P09�Q2. Not all your conclusions are correct: Claim 1 - agree time barred, Claim 2 - Valid because the strike is outside the contractor's control even though the workers are employed by the contractor. Claim 3 - agree because an Employer risk event . Claim 4 - Valid because although a V.O. and increase in quantities, it can cause the contractor to incur extra time and costs over what he planned for. However you have grasped the fundamentals.	KimberleyMcGregorsQ1.  A very adequate flow chart, with areas where client discussion needed to confirm  contract strategy also shown.  Q2.Not all your conclusions are correct: Claim 1 - The contractor is time barred. Claim 2 - agree outside contractor's control. Claim 3 - agree with your reasoning, Claim 4 - agree with your reasoning. Good descriptions of further information required. tQ1.  A very adequate flow chart, with areas where client discussion needed to confirm  contract strategy also shown.�Q2.Not all your conclusions are correct: Claim 1 - The contractor is time barred. Claim 2 - agree outside contractor's control. Claim 3 - agree with your reasoning, Claim 4 - agree with your reasoning. Good descriptions of further information required. Hilton BennieSergeBanzaIvorKarlien Rous<�seau\Q1.  This is correct because it is copy of a presentation slide.Preferable to draw your own flow chart.   Q2  Your answer is concise but accurate. Claim 1 - agree time barred. Claim 2 - Approach of the alternative of acceleration is acceptable. Claim 3 - Accept, provided the formula is in the contract. Claim 4 - Correct to examine critical path. fQ1.  This is correct because it is copy of a presentation slide.Preferable to draw your own flow chart�Q2  Your answer is concise but accurate. Claim 1 - agree time barred. Claim 2 - Approach of the alternative of acceleration is acceptable. Claim 3 - Accept, provided the formula is in the contract. Claim 4 - Correct to examine critical path. NeilSlingersNoUQ1.  Your table preceding the flow chart is informative, but to avoid "swatting a fly with a sledgehammer" one would use a Short Form of contract (FIDIC or JBCC or NEC as the case may be) and as set down at beginning of the flow chart.    Q2.  Note at Claim 1 the 28 day time bar renders the claim invalid. Claim 2 - good reasoning. Claim 3 - agree can be valid, Good observation on insurance against damage.. Claim 4 - The design changes normally come through a Variation Order (if it is a scope change then a VO is inadmissible.) If the VO causes extra work or extra time, a claim will be valid.�Q1.  Your table preceding the flow chart is informative, but to avoid "swatting a fly with a sledgehammer" one would use a Short Form of contract (FIDIC or JBCC or NEC as the case may be ans as set down at beginning of theflow chart. fQ2.  Note at Claim 1 the 28 day time bar renders the claim invalid. Claim 2 - good reasoning. Claim 3 - agree can be valid, Godd observation on insurance against damage.. Claim 4 - The design changes normally come through a Variation Order (if at is a scope change then a VO is inadmissible.) If the VO causes extra work or extra time, a claim will be valid.GustavBrand9Q1.  An acceptable and adequate flow chart, but you state JBCC Minor Works twice - for Minor Works, not Building, conditions = Fidic or NEC Short Form, not JBCC.   Q2.  This answer is concise but a correct interpretation is given for all four claims and the further information needed is appropriate in each case.�Q1.  An acceptable and adequate flow chart, but you state JBCC Minor Works twice - for Minor Works, not Building, conditions = Fidic or NEC Short Form, not JBCC.�Q2.  This answer is concise but a correct interpretation is given for all four claims and the further information needed is appropriate in each case.Zulch	MakotseneMakgalemele�Q1  This is a logical flow diagram but while the arrows define the project, the available conditions of contract are not listed - the diagram states best conditions for that  project but does not show where they come from. Also if the Employer designs and not the contractor, it must be FIDIC Red Book, not Yellow or Silver.. However you have grasped the fundamentals.   Q2.   Your reasoning whether the claims are valid or not is sound, but note on claim 4 (design changes) that even if the extra time can be accommodated in the float,(assuming the float does not in this case belong only to the contractor) it is still a claim and even if in the scope of the works, the extent of the change could not be forseen - hence a claim is valid.pQ1  This is a logical flow diagram but while the arrows define the project, the available conditions of contract are not listed - the diagram states best conditions for that  project but does not show where they come from. Also if the Employer designs and not the contractor, it must be FIDIC Red Book, not Yellow or Silver.. However you have grasped the fundamentals.oQ2.  Your reasoning whether the claims are valid or not is sound, but note on claim 4 (design changes) that even if the extra time can be accommodated in the float,(assuming the float does not in this case belong only to the contractor) it is still a claim and even if in the scope of the works, the extent of the change could not be forseen - hence a claim is valid.MarkMoore-GordonxQ1.  A very novel, but accurate way of presenting the flow chart using coloured boxes. Note FIDIC Silver Book would be used for Develop and Construct, which you have not shown, and not for Design/Build, where you already show FIDIC Yellow Book.   Q2.  A very good assessment of each claim, setting out pros and cons, plus accurate descriptions of further information required.�Q1.  A very novel, but accurate way of presenting the flow chart using coloured boxes. Note FIDIC Silver Book would be used for Develop and Construct, which you have not shown, and not for Design/Build, where you already show FIDIC Yellow Book.�Q2.  A very good assessment of each claim, setting out pros and cons, plus accurate descriptions of further information required.MbingeeHindjouEphraimThipe	SimnikiweXawukaCommon problem areas  -Assignment enhancements   {To view resubmission assessment sheet right click on "2014 Assessment Master Rev 1" and UNHIDE  "Resubmit Assessment Master%aJTo view resubmission Scoring sheet right click  and UNHIDE  "Scoring sheet<Submission1ResubmissionFINAL SCOREOrigiginal moderation DateResubmission Moderation DateScore calculated by Formula1.1 sumissio 1 or 21.2 sumission 1 or 2Score calculated by AlgorithmTo Hide:Right Click on Scoring sheetThen  Click on HIDETo openDRight Click on 2014 Assessment Rev1  Then click UNHIDE Then click OKThen  Click on UNHIDE
Then Click OK8To assess the resubmission right click ant enter Saphire6To view score sheet right click and unhide score sheetRESUBMISSIOND5E5J5F5G5HH5-Right Click on 2014  Assessment Master Rev 1 �
��cc
	�
�d-C��6?_�%���*+���&�������?'�������?(�������?)�������?�"	d,,�`�`�?�`�`�?U	}
}�
}q}L
}j
}	}�
}7}�I}		S}

�=}#}C}

�
}}
�������<��G��G��G��G��G	��b
��b��b��l
��l��l��l��l��l��l��l�@�@���
�
�
�
�	�

�

�
�
�
�
�
�
 �
!�
"�
#	�######	�

$
%�
&�
%'('%'%'%')�
*�
+
,�
-�-----�
	.�

//�
0
0�
11�
00�
11�
00�
11�
2�
33�
4�
5�
5�
5�
5�
6�
	7�

8�
5�
8�

9�
:�
;�
8�
9�
:�
;�
8�
9�
:�
;�
=�
>�
>~
?�
@ �
@!�
@ �
@ �
A"�
	@#�

B$�
C!�
B%�

C!�DEDEDEDEDF�
H�
I&�
I'~
J�
K �
K!�
K �
K �
L(�
	K#�

M)�
N!�
M*�

N!�OPOPOPOPOQ�
H�
I+�
I,~
R�
S �
S-�
S �
S �
L.�
	K#�

M/�
N-�
M0�

N-�OPOPOPOPOQ�
T�
U1�
U2~
R�
S �
S!�
S �
S �
V3�
	W#�

X4�
Y!�
X5�

Y-�Z[Z[Z[Z[Z\�
=6�
>7�
>8~
]�
^ �
^9�
^ �
^ �
A:�
	_#�

B;�
C9�
B<�

C!�DEDEDEDEDF�
	H6�
	I=�
	I>~
	R�
	` �
	`!�
	` �
	` �
	L?�
		a#�
	
M@�
	N!�
	MA�
	
N!�	OPOPOPOPOQ�

H6�

IB�

IC�0
cddddeaMNMNOPOPOPOPOQ�
T6�
UD�
UE�0fgggghWXYXYZ[Z[Z[Z[Z\�
=F�
>G�
>H~
R�
` �
`!�
` �
` �
iI�
	_#�

jJ�
k!�
jK�

C!�DEDEDEDEDF�

HF�

IL�

IM~

c�

dN�

d!�

d �

d �

mO�

	a#�


nP�

o!�

nQ�


N!�
OPOPOPOPOQ�
TF�
UR�
US~
R�
` �
`!�
` �
` �
pT�
	W#�

qU�
r!�
qV�

Y!�Z[Z[Z[Z[Z\�
sW�
>X�
>Y~
t�
uN�
u!�
u �
u �
iZ�
	_#�

j[�
k!�
j\�

C!�DEDEDEDEDF�
HW�
I]�
I^~
R�
` �
`!�
` �
` �
L_�
	a#�

M`�
N!�
Ma�

N-�OPOPOPOPOQ�
HW�
Ib�
Ic�0cddddeaMNMvOPOPOPOPOQ�
HW�
Id�
Ie�0wxxxxyaMNMvOPOPOPOPOQ�
TW�
Uf�
Ug�0fgggghWXYXzZ[Z[Z[Z[Z\�
{h�
{{�
|i�.||||||}}~~~~~~~~~~~~�
j��������}}�
k�
�l��������
�
�m��������
��		

		��8�� �(	�
���
�
3�r����X�����������������?�
�y����]�
��a<bZulch L�tter:
Brief description of the topic plus question number or sunumber eg 1, or 2a, 2b etc<a����
�
3�r����X�����������������?�
����c�]�
��,<-Zulch L�tter:
Brief description of the topic<,����
�
3�r����X�����������������?�
��L�O�]�
��,<-Zulch L�tter:
Brief description of the tipic<,����
�
3�r����X�����������������?�
��L���]�
��(<)Zulch L�tter:
Brief description of topic<(
>�@Z�	
A







gg����
	�
�d-C��6?_�%���*+���&ffffff�?'ffffff�?(�?)�?�"	d,,�`�`�?�`�`�?�cU}
}7}�
}:}x}�}	}		%}
!}""�}##�}$L	�	�$Y@$g@$@�J��$@$@$,@$,@	$@
$@$@$@
$,@$,@$,@$,@$,@$,@$,@"����������������������
	�n�6
������������������������!�
"�o�
#�p���Z�
Eval by���Z�
I Evans����Z�Date Evaluated���Z�
6,8/8, 2/9/14�
�q�Z��
�r�Z�	���Z�M3.A08   Rev 1�

�s�
�t�
�u�
�
��ffffff@������������@�����	�~
��	����"���D	�M3.A08   Rev 1#���D"�M3.A08   Rev 1�
 �
�����Z�Sub-mission no 1 or 2���Z�NKSubmitted                          on                      time      Yes/No���Z�,)Content/ Understand/ Application E/S/NE/R���Z�85Satisfactory/ Good Language/ Presentation      Yes/No���Z�=:Satisfactory/ Good Effort/Origi-nality/ Innovation  Yes/No���Z	�(A)chieved/ (N)ot achieved�
	�v�

�v�
�v�
�v�

�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
�v�
 �v�
!�v�
"�v#����Z�Celia���Z�Dyke���Z�	Ramokotjo��?Z����Z�Yes���Z�S���Z�Yes���Z�Yes���Z	�A	� @
	�+		!L�	,�B
� @

�k

aL�L	�L�L�L�L�L�L�L�L
�L�L
�L�L�L�L�7��?!Z�
B8��?"Z�B;
�%Z�YesB8�@"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:��?$Z�Yes
B:��?$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�@"Z	�A
B;�%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�!#� @D	�D"���$��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������Z�Celia���Z�
Lelethu���Z�Thiso��?Z����Z�Yes���Z�S���Z�Yes���Z�Yes���Z	�A	� @
	�+		
!L�	,�B
� @

�k


aL�L	�L�L�L�L�L�L�L�L
�L�L
�L�L�L�L�7��?!Z�
B8��?"Z�B;
�%Z�YesB8�@"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:��?$Z�Yes
B:��?$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�@"Z	�A
B;�%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�#� @
#�##
L�L�����Z�Celia���Z�	Pieter���Z�Smit��?Z����Z�Yes���Z�E���Z�Yes���Z�Yes���Z	�A	�$@
	
�$@

7��?!Z�
B8��?"Z�B;
�%Z�YesB8�@"Z	�A
B8�@"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:��?$Z�Yes
B:��?$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�@"Z	�A
B;�%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�#�$@
#���Z�Celia���Z�	Philip���Z�Lin��?Z����Z�Yes���Z�S���Z�Yes���Z�Yes���Z	�A	� @
	
� @

7��?!Z�
B8��?"Z�B;
�%Z�YesB8�@"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:��?$Z�Yes
B:��?$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�@"Z	�A
B;�%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�#� @
#���Z�Craig���Z�
Ericson���Z�	 Ntuli��?Z����Z�Yes���Z�NE���Z�Yes���Z�Yes���Z	�A	�@
	
�@

7��?!Z�
B8��?"Z�B;
�%Z�YesB8�@"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:��$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:��?$Z�Yes
B:��?$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�@"Z	�A
B;�%Z�yesB@��*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�#�@
#	���Z	�Craig	���Z	�	Kimberley	���Z	�McGregor	��?Z	�	���Z	�Yes	���Z	�S	���Z	�Yes	���Z	�Yes	���Z		�A		� @
		
� @

7	��?!Z	�
B8	��?"Z	�B;	
�%Z	�YesB8	�@"Z		�A
B8	�"Z	�E
B;	�%Z	�SNE
B:	�$Z	�NE
B9	�#Z	�R
B8	��?"Z	�R
B:	��?$Z	�Yes
B:	��?$Z	�Yes
B7	�!Z	�
B?	�)Z	�No
�?
B8	�@"Z		�A
B;	�%Z	�yesB@	�*Z	�NE�?
B�	�������!	"�Z		�	#� @
#
���Z
�Craig
���Z
�
Hilton 
���Z
�	Bennie
�Z
�
�Z
�
�Z
�
�Z
�
�Z
�
�Z
	�
	�
	

��

7
��?!Z
�
B8
��"Z
�B;

��%Z
�YesB8
�"Z
	�A
B8
�"Z
�E
B;
�%Z
�SNE
B:
�$Z
�NE
B9
�#Z
�R
B8
��?"Z
�R
B:
�$Z
�Yes
B:
�$Z
�Yes
B7
�!Z
�
B?
�)Z
�No
�?
B8
�"Z
	�A
B;
��%Z
�yesB@
�*Z
�NE�?
B�
�������!
"�Z
	�
#�
#=��Z�Craig���Z�Serge���Z�Banza�Z��Z��Z��Z��Z��Z	�	�
	
��

7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�#�
#���Z�Ivor���Z�Karlien ���Z�Rousseau��?Z����Z�Yes���Z�S���Z�Yes���Z�Yes���Z	�A	� @
	
� @

7��?!Z�
B8��?"Z�B;
�%Z�YesB8�@"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:��?$Z�Yes
B:��?$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�@"Z	�A
B;�%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�#� @
#
H��Z
�Ivor
���Z
�Neil
���Z
�Slingers
��?Z
�
���Z
�No
���Z
�S
���Z
�Yes
���Z
�Yes
���Z
	�A
	�@
	

�@

7
��?!Z
�
B8
��?"Z
�B;

��%Z
�YesB8
�@"Z
	�A
B8
�"Z
�E
B;
�%Z
�SNE
B:
�$Z
�NE
B9
�#Z
�R
B8
��?"Z
�R
B:
��?$Z
�Yes
B:
��?$Z
�Yes
B7
�!Z
�
B?
�)Z
�No
�?
B8
�@"Z
	�A
B;
��%Z
�yesB@
�*Z
�NE�?
B�
�������!
"�Z
	�
#�@
#T��Z�Ivor���Z�	Gustav���Z�Brand��?Z����Z�Yes���Z�S���Z�Yes���Z�Yes���Z	�A	� @
	
� @

7��?!Z�
B8��?"Z�B;
�%Z�YesB8�@"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:��?$Z�Yes
B:��?$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�@"Z	�A
B;�%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�#� @
#=��Z�Zulch���Z�	Makotsene���Z�Makgalemele��?Z����Z�No���Z�S���Z�Yes���Z�Yes���Z	�A	�@
	
�@

7��?!Z�
B8��?"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�@"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:��?$Z�Yes
B:��?$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�@"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�#�@
#H��Z�Zulch���Z�Mark���Z�Moore-Gordon��?Z����Z�Yes���Z�S���Z�Yes���Z�Yes���Z	�A	� @
	
� @

7��?!Z�
B8��?"Z�B;
�%Z�YesB8�@"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:��?$Z�Yes
B:��?$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�@"Z	�A
B;�%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�#� @
#H��Z�Zulch���Z�
Mbingee���Z�
Hindjou�Z��Z��Z��Z��Z��Z	�	�
	
��

7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�#�
#H��Z�Zulch���Z�
Ephraim���Z�Thipe�Z��Z��Z��Z��Z��Z	�	�
	�+		!L�	,�B
��

�k

aL�L	�L�L�L�L�L�L�L�L
�L�L
�L�L�L�L�7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�#�
#�##L�L��T��Z�Zulch���Z�	Simnikiwe���Z�	Xawuka�Z��Z��Z��Z��Z��Z	�	�
	
��

7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������!"�Z	�#�
#�
�w�
�x�
���
�y��
�z�
�{�0����������������������
�|�
���
 �}!���P�H ��0�(	�
�>�@gg����D
	�
�d-C��6?_�%���*+���&�������?'�������?(�������?)�������?�"	d,,�`�`�?�`�`�?U	}�
}�
}�
}�}
}�}�}�I}		S�}

�4}#}�/}

�
}o)}}q/}�}�/}j
}a2}�}�2}�
}
�������<X��:�����������	���
������g@
I@�@������@�@	��
!���[��M3.A08   Rev 1��
!���[�	�Conditions of Contract�����	�

��
�
�
��
��
��
��
��
 �
!�
"�
�	�������	
���Z
���Q1.  Set up a Flow chart to determine the most suitable of the four conditions of Contract (GCC, JBCC, FIDIC and NEC) for different projects, depending on size, type, designer, pricing strategy and contracting strategy.����Z���Q2. From Part C (Legal) of the Heritage Project case study , assuming GCC 2010 applies, analyse the four delay claims from the Wastewater Treatment Works contractor and determine which of them could be valid in terms of the contract (ignoring at this stage the quantum of the claims) and which could be rejected. Also, describe what further information would be required from the contractor by you as Engineer evaluating the claims, to substantiate the claims you consider to be valid 
��Z���Z���Z���Z���Z���*+,�
-�-----�
	��

11�
1
1�
11�
11�
11�
11�
11�
2�
33�
4�
5�
5�
5�
5�
6�
	��

:�
��
:�

;�
:�
;�
:�
;�
:�
;�
:�
;�
:�
;=��Z�Celia���Z�Dyke���Z�	Ramokotjo?���)Z	�AchievedBAchievedDE��.DAchieved*AssessB*E��
�8.DAchieved*AssessB*E��
*E��
*E��
*E	E��/D�Achieved*Status?B*
E��
*E��
*E��
*
E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*F��
*H��Z�Celia���Z�
Lelethu���Z�Thiso?'��)Z	�AchievedBAchievedDP��.DAchieved*AssessB*P��
�8.DAchieved*AssessB*P��
*P��
*P��
*	P��
	�9		
/L��Achieved*Status?B*
P��
*P��
*P��
*
P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*Q��
*H��Z�Celia���Z�	Pieter���Z�Smit?'��)Z	�AchievedBAchievedDP��.DAchieved*AssessB*P��
�8.DAchieved*AssessB*P��
*P��
*P��
*	P��
	*
P��
*P��
*P��
*
P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*Q��
*T��Z�Celia���Z�	Philip���Z�Lin?���)Z	�AchievedBAchievedD[��.DAchieved*AssessB*[��
�8.DAchieved*AssessB*[��
*[��
*[��
*	[��
	*
[��
*[��
*[��
*
[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*\��
*=��Z�Craig���Z�
Ericson���Z�	 Ntuli?���)Z	���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������AchievedBAchievedDE��.DAchieved*AssessB*E��
�8.DAchieved*AssessB*E��
*E��
*E��
*	E��
	*
E��
*E��
*E��
*
E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*F��
*	H��Z	�Craig	���Z	�	Kimberley	���Z	�McGregor?	'��)Z		�AchievedBAchievedD	P��.D	Achieved*AssessB*	P��
	�8		.D	Achieved*AssessB*	P��
	*	P��
	*	P��
	*		P��
	*	
P��
	*	P��
	*	P��
	*	
P��
	*	P��
	*	P��
	*	P��
	*	P��
	*	P��
	*	P��
	*	P��
	*	P��
	*	P��
	*	Q��
	*
H��Z
�Craig
���Z
�
Hilton 
���Z
�	Bennie?
'@)Z
	�AchievedBD
P��.D
Achieved*AssessB	Assess
P��

�8

.D
Achieved*AssessB	Assess
P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess
	P��
	
Status?

P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess

P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess
P��

	Assess
Q��

	AssessT��Z�Craig���Z�Serge���Z�Banza?�@)Z	�AchievedBD[��.DAchieved*AssessB	Assess[��
�8.DAchieved*AssessB	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess	[��
	
Status?
[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess
[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess\��
	Assess=��Z�Ivor���Z�Karlien ���Z�Rousseau?���)Z	�AchievedBAchievedDE��.DAchieved*AssessB*DE��.DAchieved*AssessB*E��
�8.DAchieved*AssessB*E��
*E��
*	E��
	*
E��
*E��
*E��
*
E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*F��
*
H��Z
�Ivor
���Z
�Neil
���Z
�Slingers?
'��)Z
	�AchievedBAchievedD
P��.D
Achieved*AssessB*
P��

�8

.D
Achieved*AssessB*
P��

*
P��

*
P��

*
	P��
	*

P��

*
P��

*
P��

*

P��

*
P��

*
P��

*
P��

*
P��

*
P��

*
P��

*
P��

*
P��

*
P��

*
Q��

*T��Z�Ivor���Z�	Gustav���Z�Brand?���)Z	�AchievedBAchievedD[��.DAchieved*AssessB*[��
�8.DAchieved*AssessB*[��
*[��
*[��
*	[��
	*
[��
*[��
*[��
*
[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*[��
*\��
*=��Z�Zulch���Z�	Makotsene���Z�Makgalemele?���)Z	�AchievedBAchievedDE��.DAchieved*AssessB*E��
�8.DAchieved*AssessB*E��
*E��
*E��
*	E��
	*
E��
*E��
*E��
*
E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*E��
*F��
*H��Z�Zulch���Z�Mark���Z�Moore-Gordon?'��)Z	�AchievedBAchievedDP��.DAchieved*AssessB*P��
�8.DAchieved*AssessB*P��
*P��
*P��
*	P��
	*
P��
*P��
*P��
*
P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*P��
*Q��
*H��Z�Zulch���Z�
Mbingee���Z�
Hindjou?'@)Z	�AchievedBDP��.DAchieved*AssessB	AssessP��
�86.DAchieved*AssessB	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	Assess	P��
	
Status?
P��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	Assess
P��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessQ��
	AssessH��Z�Zulch���Z�
Ephraim���Z�Thipe?'@)Z	�AchievedBP��
�8.DAchieved*AssessB	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	Assess	P��
	�9		/L��Achieved*Status?B
Status?
P��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	Assess
P��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessP��
	AssessQ��
	AssessT��Z�Zulch���Z�	Simnikiwe���Z�	Xawuka?�@)Z	�AchievedB[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess	[��
	
Status?
[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess
[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess[��
	Assess\��
	Assess�
{h�{{�������}}�
j��������}}�
�~������
���		

		��80�� �(	�
���
�
3�r����X�����������������?�
�	O
E��]�
��a<bZulch L�tter:
Brief description of the topic plus question number or sunumber eg 1, or 2a, 2b etc<a����
�
3�r����X�����������������?�
�FOF}�]�
��,<-Zulch L�tter:
Brief description of the topic<,����
�
3�r����X�����������������?�
��O�}�]�
��,<-Zulch L�tter:
Brief description of the tipic<,����
�
3�r����X�����������������?�
��O��]�
��(<)Zulch L�tter:
Brief description of topic<(
>�@U�A
gg����
	�
�d-C��6?_�%���*+���&ffffff�?'ffffff�?(�?)�?�"	d,,�`�`�?�`�`�?�cU	}
}7}�
}7}x}\
}�}		%}
}�}}
��
Y@g@@����!@!@!,@,@	@
@@@
,@,@,@,@,@,@,@"������������������������
	�����Z�
Eval by���Z�
I Evans����Z�Date Evaluated���Z�
6,8/8, 2/9/14���Z�Date Moderated�Z��
��	���Z�M3.A08   Rev 1�

�s�
�t�
�u�
�
��ffffff@������������@�����	�~
��	�����
 �
�����Z�Sub-mission no 1 or 2���Z�NKSubmitted                          on                      time      Yes/No���Z�,)Content/ Understand/ Application E/S/NE/R���Z�85Satisfactory/ Good Language/ Presentation      Yes/No���Z�=:Satisfactory/ Good Effort/Origi-nality/ Innovation  Yes/No���Z	�(A)chieved/ (N)ot achieved�
	�v
��
���
���

���
���
���
���
���
���
���
���
���
���
���
���
���
��=��Z�Celia���Z�Dyke���Z�	Ramokotjo���Z�Achieved���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z	�*7	�!D
�	$
�B
��

�k


aL�L	�L�L�L�L�L�L�L�L
�L�L
�L�L�L�L�7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B6� D�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������H��Z�Celia���Z�
Lelethu���Z�Thiso���Z�Achieved���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z	�*	�
	�+		
!L�	,�B
��

7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B�
�* L�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��
�� H��Z�Celia���Z�	Pieter���Z�Smit���Z�Achieved���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z	�*	�
	w
��aD�D�D�D
�D�D�D�D�D�D�D�D�D�D�D�D�7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B�
;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B��
�� T��Z�Celia���Z�	Philip���Z�Lin���Z�Achieved���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z	�*	�
	
��

7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B�
�� =��Z�Craig���Z�
Ericson���Z�	 Ntuli���Z�Achieved���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z	�*	�
	
��

7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B	H��Z	�Craig	���Z	�	Kimberley	���Z	�McGregor	���Z	�Achieved	���Z	�*	���Z	�*	���Z	�*	���Z	�*	���Z		�*		�
		
��

7	��?!Z	�
B8	��"Z	�B;	
��%Z	�YesB8	�"Z		�A
B8	�"Z	�E
B;	�%Z	�SNE
B:	�$Z	�NE
B9	�#Z	�R
B8	��?"Z	�R
B:	�$Z	�Yes
B:	�$Z	�Yes
B7	�!Z	�
B?	�)Z	�No
�?
B8	�"Z		�A
B;	��%Z	�yesB@	�*Z	�NE�?
B
H��Z
�Craig
���Z
�
Hilton 
���Z
�	Bennie
�@Z
�
���Z
�	Assess
���Z
�	Assess
���Z
�	Assess
���Z
�	Assess
���Z
	�
Status?
	�
	

��

7
�!Z
�
B8
��"Z
�B;

��%Z
�YesB8
�"Z
	�A
B8
�"Z
�E
B;
�%Z
�SNE
B:
�$Z
�NE
B9
�#Z
�R
B8
��?"Z
�R
B:
�$Z
�Yes
B:
�$Z
�Yes
B7
��?!Z
�
B?
�)Z
�No
�?
B8
�"Z
	�A
B;
��%Z
�yesB@
�*Z
�NE�?
BT��Z�Craig���Z�Serge���Z�Banza�@Z����Z�	Assess���Z�	Assess���Z�	Assess���Z�	Assess���Z	�
Status?	�
	
��

7�!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7��?!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B=��Z�Ivor���Z�Karlien ���Z�Rousseau���Z�Achieved���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z	�*	�
	
��

7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B
H��Z
�Ivor
���Z
�Neil
���Z
�Slingers
���Z
�Achieved
���Z
�*
���Z
�*
���Z
�*
���Z
�*
���Z
	�*
	�
	

��

7
��?!Z
�
B8
��"Z
�B;

��%Z
�YesB8
�"Z
	�A
B8
�"Z
�E
B;
�%Z
�SNE
B:
�$Z
�NE
B9
�#Z
�R
B8
��?"Z
�R
B:
�$Z
�Yes
B:
�$Z
�Yes
B7
�!Z
�
B?
�)Z
�No
�?
B8
�"Z
	�A
B;
��%Z
�yesB@
�*Z
�NE�?
BT��Z�Ivor���Z�	Gustav���Z�Brand���Z�Achieved���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z	�*	�
	
��

7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
B=��Z�Zulch���Z�	Makotsene���Z�Makgalemele���Z�Achieved���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z	�*	�
	
��

7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
BH��Z�Zulch���Z�Mark���Z�Moore-Gordon���Z�Achieved���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z�*���Z	�*	�
	
��

7��?!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7�!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
BH��Z�Zulch���Z�
Mbingee���Z�
Hindjou�@Z����Z�	Assess���Z�	Assess���Z�	Assess���Z�	Assess���Z	�
Status?	�
	
��

7�!Z�
B8��"Z�B;
��%Z�YesB8�"Z	�A
B8�"Z�E
B;�%Z�SNE
B:�$Z�NE
B9�#Z�R
B8��?"Z�R
B:�$Z�Yes
B:�$Z�Yes
B7��?!Z�
B?�)Z�No
�?
B8�"Z	�A
B;��%Z�yesB@�*Z�NE�?
BH��Z�Zulch���Z�
Ephraim���Z�Thipe�@Z����Z�	Assess���Z�	Assess���Z�	Assess���Z�	Assess���Z	�
Status?	�
	�+		!L�	,�B�(
�����������������T��Z�Zulch���Z�	Simnikiwe���Z�	Xawuka�@Z����Z�	Assess���Z�	Assess���Z�	Assess���Z�	Assess���Z	�
Status?	�
	�(
������������������
�w�
�x�
���
�y��
�z�
���0����������������������
�|�
���
 �}!��
#��P�H@��0�(	�
�>�@   gg����D
������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������
�����FMicrosoft Excel 97-TabelleBiff8����Oh��+'��0|8	@
LXd
p�0@@@@����՜.��+,��D��՜.��+,��\��Root Entry���������F�Workbook������CompObj��������IOle
������������SummaryInformation(���������DocumentSummaryInformation8������������t��������������������������������